Buyer's guide

Find your filter.

Five types of water filter, compared honestly: what each one removes, where it goes and what it takes to keep it running.

Published · Updated

Short answer

Pick a filter for the specific thing you want to reduce, not just for the type of filter. First find out what's in your water: your water utility's annual Consumer Confidence Report covers public water, and a certified lab test covers a private well. Then choose a product whose certification covers that exact contaminant (a standard number alone isn't enough), and replace cartridges on schedule. Some households may not need treatment at all.

At a glance

Side by side.

"Range" is our relative guide to how broad a set of contaminants a typical certified system of that type can reduce. It is not a test result. Always check the exact model's certified claims.

Five types of water filter compared by use, what they can reduce when certified, relative range, installation and maintenance
TypeBest forCan reduce (if certified)RangeInstallMaintenance
Reverse osmosisDrinking & cooking waterA wide range of dissolved contaminants, such as lead, arsenic, nitrate or fluoride, when the specific model is certified for them (NSF/ANSI 58). Carbon stages handle chlorine taste and odor.Under sink; needs a drain line and dedicated faucetPre/post filters every 6–12 months; membrane every 2–3 years
CountertopRenters, small kitchensChlorine taste and odor (NSF/ANSI 42). Some models are also certified for lead or other contaminants (NSF/ANSI 53 or 401); check the exact claim.Sits on the counter or attaches to the faucet; no plumbingCartridge every 2–6 months
Under counterEveryday filtered tap waterChlorine taste and odor and sediment. Multi-stage models may be certified for lead or cysts (NSF/ANSI 53); check the exact claim.Under sink, on the cold line; optional separate faucetCartridges every 6–12 months
ShowerSkin, hair & chlorine sensitivityFree chlorine (the claim NSF/ANSI 177 covers). A shower filter is not a water softener.Screws between the shower arm and headCartridge every 3–6 months
Whole houseProtecting the whole homeSediment and chlorine taste and odor at every tap. Chloramine usually needs catalytic carbon; check the system's claims.Point of entry on the main line; often professional installSediment every 3–6 months; carbon tank or cartridge per rating

Questions

Good to know.

How do I know what's in my water?

If you're on municipal water, your utility publishes an annual Consumer Confidence Report. On a private well, get a certified lab test. Choose your filter based on what's actually in your water.

What do NSF/ANSI certifications mean?

They're independent standards for what a filter has been tested to reduce. NSF/ANSI 42 covers aesthetic effects like chlorine taste and odor, 53 covers named health-related contaminants such as lead, 58 covers reverse osmosis systems, 401 covers certain emerging contaminants, and 177 covers shower filters' free-chlorine reduction. Each product is certified for specific contaminants, so check the model's listing, not just the standard number.

Does reverse osmosis remove healthy minerals?

Yes, along with the contaminants. Most people get their minerals from food, but if you prefer the taste, a remineralizing post-filter adds calcium and magnesium back.

Can I combine filters?

Yes, and many homes do: a whole-house system for sediment and chlorine, plus reverse osmosis at the kitchen sink for drinking water.

What happens if I don't change my cartridges?

Saturated media stops working and clogged filters can slow your flow. Follow the manufacturer's schedule, and change them sooner if you notice taste, odor or flow changes.

Still deciding?

Talk to us.

Call 24x7 or send a message and we'll point you in the right direction.

Call us24x7Rancho Cordova, CA